Guest Stars Beau Wirick as Sean Donahue Brock Ciarlelli as Brad Bottig Jen Ray as Nancy Donahue Daniela Bobadilla as Lexie Brooks Pat Finn as Bill Norwood Sean O'Bryan as Ron Donahue Katlin Mastandrea as Ashley Paul Hipp as Reverend TimTom Terrence Beasor as Mr. Johnson Luenell as Security Woman David Figlioli as Security Man Co Starring Laura Ann Kesling as Dotty Donahue Kayla Madison as Shelly Donahue Beau Hart as Riley O'Neill Monahan as Lucas Reagan Rundus as Gracie Heather Olt as Paramedic Allan Fisher as Axl's future son #2 Corwin Allard as Kid at Book Signing Toby Grey as Axl's future son #1 Josiah Cerio as Axl's future son #3