Guest Stars Justin Kirk as Peter Tara Lipinski as Herself Ginger Gonzaga as Vivian Co Starring Alex Raul Barrios as Derrell Coda Boesel as B.D. Juliocesar Chavez as Gigs Julitta Dee Scheel as Cassidy Patrick Johnson as The Oops / Maestro Fermata / Puppeteer Mary Faber as Macy Joel Swetow as Rabbi Michael Epstein Zackary Arthur as Young Jeff Samira Izadi as Shelly Pinsker Natasha Khawja as Grace Kisakye Grace Su as Saks Salesperson Heather Horton as Mom Austin Zajur as Diego Illisa Lupercio as Slack Jawed Kid David Karelin as Snack Counter Boy Brayden Titus as Opponent