Guest Stars Sebastian Sozzi as Carlos Garcia Michael Gladis as Pastor Hollis Monroe Ritesh Rajan as Doctor Anit Choudhury Derek Phillips as Danny Wallace Co Starring Kayvon Esmaili as Brian Seldes Landon Gimenez as Jacob Wallace Nancy De Mayo as Laura Nygard Harry Zinn as Chief Burrows Erika Bowman as CPS Worker Tamarra Graham as Kathy Bainbridge Mia Grace Davila as Lizzie Wallace Mary Claire Garcia as Melissa Wallace