Guest Stars Alyssa Diaz as Teresa Zach Grenier as Ed Feratti Domenick Lombardozzi as Sean "Mac" McGrath Lola Glaudini as Anita Novak Chris Tardio as Danny Bianchi Tony Curran as Sgt. Mikey "Rad" Radulovic Max Casella as Emerson Lake Jacob Ming-Trent as Big Easy Michael J. Burg as Ron Klitstein Co Starring Sasha Kali Kadri as Maria Donovan Olivia Jennah Kadri as Maria Donovan Michael Imperiale as Ring Leader Jillian Lindig as New York Dame Jamar Greene as Check Cashing Guard Chris Barnes as Jitney Bus Driver Pat Bowie as Old African-American Lady Kymbali Craig as Officer Pam Chris McGinn as Check Cashing Woman #3 Pamela Afesi as Check Cashing Woman #2 Marlene Hodgdon as Check Cashing Woman #1 Rick Crom as Actual Priest Danny Doherty as Military Guy Tom Flynn as Wealthy Man