Guest Stars Caroline Aaron as Shirley Maisel Joel Johnstone as Archie Cleary Brian Tarantina as Jackie Will Brill as Noah Weissman Justine Lupe as Astrid Weissman Emily Bergl as Tessie Zachary Levi as Benjamin Ettenberg Rufus Sewell as Declan Howell P.J. Marshall as Skint Lynn Cohen as Bubbabosia Daniel Stewart Sherman as Artie Co Starring Matteo Pascale as Ethan Nunzio Pascale as Ethan Matilda Szydagis as Zelda Cynthia Darlow as Mrs. Moskowitz Teddy Coluca as Manny Colby Minifie as Ginger Megan McGinnis as Loula Bern Cohen as Rabbi Krinsky Alison Smith as Jane Jacobs Adam B. Shapiro as Cantor Charissa Hogeland as Florence Joel Rooks as Lutzi Neiderman William Ryall as Manfred Jean Brassard as Pere Juan Carlos Díaz as Drunk Guy Mark Aldrich as Bartender Joshua Zisholtz as Male Customer Jeremy Shinder as Cantor's Son Elizabeth Loyacano as Customer Leah Curney as Artsy Woman Tania Asnes as Agnes Reynolds Brian Myers Cooper as Art Patron #1 Carine Montbertrand as Art Patron #2 Noriko Sato as Japanese Woman Devon Diffenderfer as Delivery Boy Anni Krueger as Velma Caitlin Wilayto as Julie Uncredited Bob Leszczak as Maisel and Roth Supervisor