Guest Stars Ned Schmidtke as Father Matthew Adam Busch as Wes John Diehl as David Burke Elizabeth Ann Bennett as Holly Audrey Marie Anderson as Isabell Kramer Matt Lanter as Nick Aaron Paul as Mark Owens Randy Oglesby as Father David Co Starring Marnie Crossen as Mrs. Havelock Bonnie Brewster as Shannon / Receptionist Lorin McCraley as Derelict Nicole Monica as Teenage Girl Nathaniel McGarity as Teenage Boy