Special Guest Stars Chloë Sevigny as Shelley Guest Stars Jenna Dewan as Teresa Morrison Mark Consuelos as Spivey Mark Margolis as Sam Goodman Kasey Mahaffy as Father James Amy Farrington as Mrs. Reynolds Eugene Byrd as Grayson's Partner David Gianopoulos as Det. John Grayson Nikki Hahn as Jenny Reynolds Bob Bancroft as Harry Kirkland Kirk Bovill as Phil Co Starring Tara Holt as Laura Michael Duisenberg as Male Uniform Adrian Quiñonez as Uni Cop Parker York Smith as Giles Cheyenne Wilbur as Professor Betty Murphy as Sally Starns Brooke Hasalton as Mom