Guest Stars Yara Martinez as Isabella Colón Reiko Aylesworth as Carolyn Kelly Alex Carter as James Weeks Josh Cooke as Kevin Weeks Tovah Feldshuh as Judge Garner Joanna P. Adler as Dr. Judy Barnes Elizabeth Rich as Leslie Garfield Co Starring Lenny Delgado as Priest Samantha Rivers Cole as Juror #11 Nicholas Velez as Sai