Guest Stars Ryan Caltagirone as Hot Dad Patricia Belcher as Mavis Trevor Larcom as Blake Kelly Frye as Gina Meyers Drew Droege as Paul Ballenger Matt Besser as Kev Dibbons Co Starring Ella Gross as Julie Robyn Okrant as Donna Caden Dragomer as Harrison Sawyer Cole as Nicholas Jessica Pressley as Hillary Ezra Dewey as Rhett