Guest Stars Suzzanne Douglas as Grace Cuffee Len Cariou as DA Robert Morgenthau Adepero Oduye as Nomsa Brath William Sadler as Detective Michael Sheehan Omar J. Dorsey as Elombre Brath Alexandra Templer as Trisha Meili Denia Brache as Natividad Blair Underwood as Bobby Burns Christopher Jackson as Peter Rivera Chukwudi Iwuji as Colin Moore Joshua Jackson as Mickey Joseph Frank Pando as Detective Gonzales Kate Easton as Patricia Dean Todd Lawson as John Loughlin Caroline Hewitt as Local News Reporter Edward Carnevale as Court Clerk Jayce Bartok as Detective Hildebrandt Pernell Walker as Gina Smith Richard Bekins as Judge Galligan Leigh DeLollis as Juror 4 Juri Henley-Cohn as Dr. Kurtz Robert McKay as Juror 3 Walker Hare as Agent Adams Ben Jacoby as White Male Newscaster 2 Alex Breaux as Tim Clements Kris Arnold as Reporter Reggie A. Green as Black Supporter Kym Gomes as Juror 1 Joseph Adams as Editor Allan Greenberg as Howard Diller Christine Spang as Latino Newscaster Doug Barron as Juror 2 J. Bernard Calloway as Reverend