Guest Stars Drew Tanner as Fangs Fogarty Alvin Sanders as Pop Tate Molly Ringwald as Mary Andrews Trinity Likins as Jellybean Jones Zoé De Grand Maison as Evelyn Evernever Eli Goree as Mad Dog Chad Michael Murray as Edgar Evernever Luvia Petersen as Counselor Brooke Rivers Co Starring Nikolai Witschl as Dr. Curdle Jr. Marion Eisman as Doris Bell Bernadette Beck as Peaches 'N Cream Andrew Wheeler as Marco Marquez Angela Vanderwal as Appraiser Carlo Fortin as Stu Ethan Shankaruk as Masked Court Jester