Guest Stars Caitlin Mehner as Heather Husband Candice Coke as Wren Catherine Lidstone as Isabel Sanchez Tiffany Dupont as Nikki Castro Jeffrey Nordling as Rick Zahn Adam Busch as Noah Weiss Patrick Mulvey as ASA Gerald Warren Genevieve VenJohnson as Judge Siobhan Gleason Josue Aguirre as Hector Costa Co Starring Casey Tutton as Rosemary Lynch James Farruggio as ASA Duncan Heidi Johanningmeier as Linda Barrett Ricky J. Hawk as Nathan Grace Fahey as Young Heather Jennifer Estlin as Judge Cohen Maggie Scrantom as Sarah Tawney Isabel Kaegi as Young Sarah Ingrid Hanson-Tuntland as Guard #1 Jibreel Tracy as Guard #2 Ben Page as Ice Officer Jacob Perez as Leonardo Elena Tubridy as Young Linda Lenny Pagan as Alberto Granados Renata Walsh as Reporter #1 Dana Black as U.S. Attorney Maureen Riley Johnny Arena as Dr. Benjamin Lovatt Timothy W. Hull as Stephen Brennan Jordan Brodess as Reporter #2 Andre Truss as Harkins Kelli Simpkins as Reverend Shirley Malloy Daniela Colucci as Daniella Castro Ana Maria Alvarez as Isidora Costa Jose Antonio Garcia as Judge Samuel Gomez