Guest Stars Adam Beach as Chief McGinnis Sara Canning as Katherine Drew Pamela Sue Martin as Harriet Grosset Co Starring Stephanie Van Dyck as Dead Lucy Sinead Curry as Tiffany Hudson Eden Summer Gilmore as Young Nancy Kurt Long as Nathan Gomber Gage Marsh as Boyfriend Jasmine Vega as Nancy's Friend #2 Emma Oliver as 4-year-old Nancy Will Chilton as Security Guard Jenika Rose as Nancy's Friend #1