Guest Stars Liza Lapira as Mia Omar Maskati as Elias Dale Dickey as RoseMarie Kai Lennox as Steve Rasmussen Scott Lawrence as Special Agent Billy Taggart Eric Lange as Detective Parker Danielle MacDonald as Amber Stevenson Austin Hébert as Max Duvall Elizabeth Marvel as Judith Shane Paul McGhie as Connor Annaleigh Ashford as Lilly Darrow Bridget Everett as Colleen Doggett Nick Searcy as Deteective Harkness Rob Welsh as Nathan Dale Godboldo as Kansas Detective Co Starring Blake Ellis as Chris McCarthy Treisa Gary as Evelyn Allius Barnes as Remy Darin Cooper as Creepy Diner Guy Mike McColl as Detective Baskerville Trevor Black as Pastor Mara Casey as Trish Julia Griswold as Coed