Guest Stars Elyse Levesque as Patience Courtney Henggeler as Anna Barker Reign Edwards as Cody Kerr Smith as Shane Barker Antonio Raul Corbo as Tate Barker Peter Giles as Ethan Taj Speights as Finn Co Starring David Mattey as Big Pilgrim Kathryn Taylor Smith as Cody's Mom Beth Curry as Katherine Dana L. Wilson as Gina Perry Smith as Lady Pilgrim Tessa Goss as Diane Charles Currier as Elder Pilgrim