Guest Stars Nicole Shalhoub as Vanessa Dudley Clark Johnson as Father Amara Karen Pittman as Caroline Hopkins Chris Ghaffari as Tony Pacuci Matilda Lawler as Brenda Timothy D. Stickney as William Hopkins Gregg Edelman as Rodney Match Co Starring David Adkins as Pierre Halley Raelle Sacar Stevens as Hayley Lizan Mitchell as Crying Aunt Victoria Meade as Caliente Day Jake Ryan Lozano as Dougie Martin Brianne James as Kelsey