Guest Stars Kelly Frye as Kristy Simmons Dorian Harewood as Fred Kirkman Andi Chapman as Laura Kirkman Will Tranfo as Shelby Mattson Co Starring Declan Whaley as David Simmons Ezra Dewey as Jake Simmons Kaylee Quach as Lily Simmons Genevieve Quach as Chloe Simmons Shaw Jones as Colin Ainsworth Chanté Bowser as Rhonda Kirkman Wolfgang Schaeffer as Young Shelby Mattson James Tumminia as Dr. Malcolm Delaney Thomas Blake, Jr. as Wayne Beecher Darielle Dorsey as Sophia Kirkman Alyssa Rayomie Tibbs as Officer Coleman