Guest Stars Katherine LaNasa as Noa Havilland Billy Miller as Alex Dunn Annabella Sciorra as Erin Buhrman Nicholas Bishop as Chuck Buhrman Brett Cullen as Owen Cave Molly Hagan as Susan Carver Andy Mackenzie as Rodgers Abby Brammell as TBD Arianna Ortiz as Detective Theresa Ribero Noel Arthur as TBD Co Starring Hunter Doohan as Teenage Warren Mayson Weinstein as Young Josie Stella Weinstein as Young Lanie Rebecca Huey as Teenage Josie Caroline Huey as Teenage Lanie Colby French as Detective Hunter Desiree Hall as Rosemary Jance Enslin as Jeremy / Grandson Al Pugliese as Harlan Walsh Scott Subiono as Detective Clark Stitt Andrew Carter as Rafe Polin Bruce Katzman as Dr. Ian Poole Brett Brock as Corrigan Ari Frenkel as Michael