Guest Stars Ben Rosenfield as John Schlafly Cindy Drummond as Lottie Beth Hobbs Annie Parisse as Midge Costanza Jake Lacy as Stanley Pottinger Co Starring Julia Lalonde as Anne Schlafly Ethan Hektor as Andy Schlafly Brendan Cox as Bruce Schlafly Olivia Scriven as Phyl/Liza Schlafly Marcia Bennett as Dadie Stewart Melissa Joyner as Audrey Rowe Colom Novie Edwards as Willie B. Reed Jordan Kenny as Roger Schlafly Alison Brooks as Rep. Ginny Chapman David Eisner as Martin Abzug Anna Douglas as Jean O'Leary Helen King as States Conferences Coordinator Ryan Kotack as Jacob Michael Hughes as Ryan David Tompa as Male Commissioner Chris Locke as Pie Kill Agent / Pie Thrower Douglas E. Hughes as Illinois Auditorium Senator Alexandra Floras-Matic as Beth Kevin Whalen as Pie-in-the-Face Photographer Carter Siddall as Family Christmas Photographer