Guest Stars Shaun Sipos as Trevor Boyd John Cothran, Jr. as Judge Perry Webb Jason Marsden as Kelso Sutton Jeffrey D. Sams as Julian Cook Kathleen York as Jillian Parks John D'Aquino as Ty Bennings Kaylee Defer as Katie Dobbs Paul Wesley as Justin Bishop David Clayton Rogers as Brody Miller Jack Plotnick as Bradley Roberts Rob Brownstein as Judge Wycoff Chris Payne Gilbert as Rob Bishop Ramy Zada as Andy Zahai Co Starring Phoebe Holston as Foreman Bart Blackwell as Shaun Mason Jack Weber as Kid