Special Guest Stars Blythe Danner as Demeter Guest Stars Herizen F. Guardiola as Oshun Julia Sweeney as Ann-Marie Hinzelmann Karen Glave as Aye Eric Johnson as Chad Mulligan Lela Loren as Marguerite Olsen Gil Bellows as Bill Sanders Nabeel El Khafif as Hank Sebastian Spence as Larry Hutchinson Andrew Gillies as Woody Co Starring Bridget Ogundipe as Yemoja Gabriel Mattka as Leon Olsen Gwynne Phillips as Colonial Demeter Katy Breier as Janice Jennifer Krukowski as Laura's Father's Friend #7 Courtney Lamanna as Laura's Father's Friend #3 Christie Stewart as Hotel Clerk Cynthia Preston as Jennifer Hutchinson Travis Milne as Laura's Father Samantha Belfitt as Emma Weber Sochi Fried as Usherette Shayla Fagan as Julia Weber Sarah McVie as Agatha Kevin Vidal as Greeter Cassidy Civiero as Laura's Father's Friend #5 Owen Ois as Boy Sammi Barber as Laura's Father's Friend #2 Cait Alexander as Laura's Father's Friend #1 Colin Doyle as Information Specialist Rosie Mae as Laura's Father's Friend #6 Elle McAdam as Young Laura Celeste Bruno as Beautiful Woman Jensen Porter as Laura's Father's Friend #4 Natalie Marjanovic as Laura's Father's Friend #8