Guest Stars Chelsea Spack as Kristen Kringle Michelle Veintimilla as Bridgit Pike / Firefly Ian Quinlan as Carl Pinkney Ron Rifkin as Father Creel Lucas Salvagno as Sal Martinez Paulina Singer as Josie Mac Michael Potts as Sid Bunderslaw Lenny Platt as Luke Garrett Leo Fitzpatrick as Joe Pike Noah Robbins as Evan Pike Mary Joy as Edwidge Co Starring Ari McKay Wilford as Cale Pike Sean Patrick Folster as Stretch Fenton Lawless as Clerk Sophie Lee Morris as Celestine Wayne Brian S. Carpenter as Jonathan Wayne Bryan Howard Conner as Caleb Wayne Gregory Chater as Nervous Man