Guest Stars Brianna Baker as Nancy Gillian Colleen Foy as Whitney Tanner Zagarino as Donovan Kimmy Shields as Sheila Bevin Bru as Sophia Jim Ortlieb as Frank Anton Starkman as Keith Henry Joseph Samiri as Shaun Tajh Bellow as Andrew Co Starring Sebrina Purcell as Officer Lexi Mitchell Sachie Alessio as Dr. Annabelle Tran Annie Abbott as Kind Old Lady Roger J. Timber as Grocery Store Employee Arabella Grant as Girl Kyle Ellis Lester as Male Jock #1 Rachel Thundat as Female Jock #1