Special Guest Stars Gary Cole as Kurt McVeigh Guest Stars Stephen Lang as David Cord Blake Morris as Bailiff Dean Rush Tony Plana as Oscar Rivi Anthony Cochrane as James Winston Alok Tewari as Osman Bin Ansari Mark Deklin as Wick Stilton Wanda Sykes as Allegra Durado Stephanie Nogueras as Isabel Rivi Christian Borle as Carter Schmidt Brandon Mendez Homer as Jesus CCH Pounder as Vinetta Clark Joshua De Jesus as Matteo Vargas George R. Sheffey as Officer Bellamy Daniel Bellomy as Levi Austin Pendleton as Dr. Goat Jacob Daniel Smith as Gideon Brian Dykstra as Mr. Holzapple Co Starring Samaria Nixon-Fleming as Paralegal Louisa Michael Thomas Holmes as Horace Carruthers Brandon Kazen-Maddox as Hughes Ben Biggers as Jimmy J. Stephen Brantley as Bearded Enthusiast Twinkle Burke as Mrs. Harbor Marc Koeck as Tully Britt Faulkner as Betty Patrick Noonan as Elton Beethovan Oden as Troy Eddie Korbich as Captive Neighbor Geoffrey Allen Murphy as Bob David Baida as Court Clerk