Guest Stars Alison Rich as Melanie Gideon Glick as Jess Tuc Watkins as Troy Marcia DeBonis as Kathy Noah Galvin as Eddie Debi Mazar as Herself Co Starring Cullen Wheeler as Pat! Show A.D. Noam Ash as Grindr Guy Miche Braden as Woman #1 Liz McCartney as Sweet Midwestern Lady #2 Kristine Zbornik as Nadine Wynne Anders as Sweet Midwestern Lady #1 Mary Crosbi as Pam Jenny Lester as Stephanie