Guest Stars Josh Segarra as Lance Arroyo Wanda Sykes as Shuli Kucerac Alison Rich as Melanie Nadia Dajani as Mackenzie Tavi Gevinson as Herself Co Starring Donovan E. Mitchell as Ethan Brandon Haagenson as Another Guy Mariette Booth as Audience Member #1 Alexandria Benford as Makeup Artist Regina Ohashi as Audience Member #2 Antu Yacob as Dina Andrea Negrete as Shopper Samantha Rosentrater as Carla Waliek Crandall as Security Guard Mike Dobbins as Grip Matthew Dunivan as Photographer Alex Wyse as Elliott Nora Hummel as Phyllis