Guest Stars Olivia Luccardi as Lily Day Drew Scheid as Travis Hupp Ben Chase as Nate Swanson Patricia French as Minnie Alice Barrett Mitchell as Cathy Singer Rachael Thompson as Tina Jeffrey Ryan Baker as Louis Gumpenberger Kerry Cahill as Carol Alford Cuyle Carvin as Detective Brian Hilke Co Starring Keith Morrison voices Narrator Michael Hinson as Channel 2 Reporter Dane Davenport as Mike Wood Sarah Stipe as Sarah Becki Davis as Louis' Mom Jessie Terrebonne as O'Fallon 911 Operator Jeremy Dean as Officer Carrigan Kurt McKinney as Judge Cunningham Luke Sexton as PV Fake Louis (Stunt) Jay Pennington as Bradford Kessler Liz Reinhardt Delsa as Reporter #1