Guest Stars Marlo Kelly as Jamie Murdock Shareena Clanton as Valerie Anthony Sharpe as Erik Cowie Dean Winters as Jeff Lowe Alexandra Jensen as Chealsi Putnam Benedict Hardie as Agent Thomas Ken Radley as Allen Glover Carie Kawa as Agent Nishida Fiona Press as Shirley Schreibvogel Joel Marsh Garland as James Garretson Tom Rodgers as Dillon Passage Aliandra Calabrese as Lauren Lowe Anita Hegh as Amanda Green Darren Gilshenan as John M. Phillips Bryan Probets as Judge Co Starring Daniel Reader as Arthur Daniel Potts as Prison Guard Trish Harris as Court Sketch Artist Dale Heywood as Federal Marshal David Cook as Federal Marshal Jeremiah Way as Young Agent Tyran Stig as Juror Sarah Huston as Juror Charlotte Wilson as Juror Liam Caven as Kid with Look-a-Like Victoria Darbo as Joe Female Look-a-Like Kate Peters as Juror Kaushik Das as Mr Manoharan Al Gibson as Juror Caroline O'Connor as Deanna Ann Leung as Juror Ethan Lwin as Inmate Dorsey Garth Edwards as Bailiff Lakota Johnson as Juror Emma Jones as Jury Foreperson Luke Mullins as Eric Goode