Guest Stars Olivia Luccardi as Lily Day Drew Scheid as Travis Hupp Ben Chase as Nate Swanson Jesse Scott Egan as Detective Michael Merkel Alice Barrett Mitchell as Cathy Singer Rachael Thompson as Tina Catherine Carlen as Bonnie Celia Weston as Shirley Neumann Emily Topper as Young Pam Co Starring Keith Morrison voices Narrator Lara Grice as Cousin Mary Susan Shalhoub Larkin as Luci Michael Hinson as Channel 2 Reporter Samantha Beaulieu as Friendly Nurse Ann Mahoney as Tammy Sarah Stipe as Sarah Michael Krikorian as Greg Chatton Billy Slaughter as Scott Alec James Zais as Young Mark Hupp Kyler Porche as Randy Gunderson René J.F. Piazza as Auctioneer 1 Didi Costine as Teen Witch Madeline Colombo as Bubbly Acolyte An Hoch as Cybercrimes Expert Harper Grace Herrin as Sarah at 6 Years Old Clayton Eustis as Sarah at 11 Years Old Douglas M. Griffin as Judge Ohmer