Guest Stars Sydney Cole Alexander as Natalie Michael Siberry as James Eagan Co Starring Marc Geller as Kier Eagan Annie McNamara as Danise Grace Rex as Rebeck Donald Webber, Jr. as Patton Samantha Farrow as Woman in Bride Mask Olivia Alboher as Woman in Old Woman Mask Sara King Gold as Woman in Jester Mask Weston Krukow as Man in Sheep's Head Mask Tara Rodriguez as Choreographer