Guest Stars Robert Crayton as Ron Guerette Maria Dizzia as Lori Campbell Cory Scott Allen as Art Holland Cullen Moss as Jim Hardin Trini Alvarado as Patty Peterson Teri Wyble as Sonya Pfeiffer Co Starring Kevin Sizemore as Mark Zamperini Myke Holmes as Duane Deaver Ryan Lewis as Bruce Campbell Hannah Pniewski as Becky Eric Lee as Judge Orlando Hudson Paul Vincent Freeman as POD C.O. #1 Deja Dee as Evelyn Ivins David Silverman as Carl Nick Basta as George Kynzie Colmery as Clayton's Daughter 2 Nora Seyfried as Clayton's Daughter 1 Michelle Rivera as Diane Adam Klein as Amalfi Waiter Brian Duckson as 2011 Bailiff Katherine Morón as Baja Palace Waitress Stacy Sheets as Nervous Woman Muretta Moss as Local News Anchor Ro Underwood as DA Tracey Cline Emma Coulter as Amalfi Hostess Micah Shane Ballinger as Waiter Ben Franczuszki as ADA Jim Dornfried Alison Bell as 2011 Court Clerk Christopher Speed as Editor