Guest Stars Jennifer Ferrin as D.A. Avery Grafton Andrew Rothenberg as Judge R. Meyerson Jade Eshete as Kerry Jacobs Rosa Arredondo as Sofia RJ Brown as Tim Colvin Rachel Nicks as Morgan Carver John Bedford Lloyd as Howard Co Starring Amel Khalil as Nina Robert Keiley as Sarah's Dad Daniel Hepner as Juror 11 Gayle Samuels as Jeanie Sam Pearson as Keeley Emma Welch as Sarah's Mom Justin Dean as Court Officer Brian Dives as Devin Ellis Diane Dehn as Juror 10 Josh Drake as Christian Messina Kate Pak as Juror 9 Javier Sanchez as Juror 12 Yainis Ynoa as Olivia Simmons Graham Powell as Detective Frank Rodriguez as Alan Desoto James Adam Lim as Ji-Yoon