Guest Stars Ariana DeBose as Maya Michael Malarkey as Emmett Manny Montana as Carver Aaron Stanford as Peter Myers Liza Weil as Deborah Josh Randall as Jim Navarro Lili Simmons as Sophia Saffron Burrows as Anastasia Whitney José Zúñiga as Vice President Jack Coleman as Senator Ken Whitney Co Starring Ted Monte as Arthur Reeves Gabriel Bonilla as Gerald Justin Zachary as Bartender Natalia Lazarus as Rosa