Guest Stars Denis O'Hare as Spalding Van Wirt Kristine Frøseth as Coby Rae Dellum Matt Lasky as Eustace Abby Corrigan as Aurelia Caitlin Dulany as Elder Witch Houston Jax Towe as Otis Van Wirt Simone Recasner as Harlene Emily Morales-Cabrera as Bonnie Maryssa Menendez as Faye Co Starring Genevieve Aitken as Ellen Van Wirt Simon Potter as Lover Cosima Cabrera as Young Witch Ellie Grace Pomeroy as Young Myrtle Snow