Guest Stars William Reynolds as Bill Gregg Frank Cady as Hamelin George O'Hanlon as Charlie Caldwell William H. Wright as Jabe Hallock Harry Harvey as Store Owner Don Beddoe as Price Hugh Sanders as Blaine Emile Meyer as Pike Tol Avery as John Sloan Joan Marshall as Lucy Sutter Tom Monroe as Slim Harry Cheshire as Judge Donald Kirke as First Juror Ken Christy as Sheriff Robert Lynn as Doctor Uncredited William H. O'Brien as Juror Luis Delgado as Trial Spectator Brandon Beach as Juror Steve Carruthers as Juror Paul Kruger as Juror Jack Henderson as Juror