Guest Stars Rachel Ticotin as Joy Sullivan Aaronson Jason Manuel Olazábal as Todd Mercer Shane Blades as Tony Sadie Stratton as Renee Watts Jason MacDonald as John Watts Austin Cauldwell as Ryan Aaronson Brenda Kate as Sheila Co Starring Warren Sweeney as Priest Kathryn Melton as Cleaning Lady Nicole Rainteau as Kaytlynn Leah Grosjean as Navy Ensign Ashley Watts