Guest Stars Nick Swardson as Terry Bernadino Toby Huss as Big Mike Wanru Tseng as Cindy Gary Anthony Williams as Ronnie Donald Ceviche Bobby Moynihan as Christopher Richnickie Jim Jefferies as Australian Tourist John Ross Bowie as Belphegor Marc Evan Jackson as Gunner Kulap Vilaysack as Bell Ringer #1 Michael Ian Black as Hatzalah Commander Parvesh Cheena as State Trooper Bert Jill Basey as Nora the Senior Citizen Jessica Betts as Inkeba Bathetois Jenny Robertson as Bus Driver Courtney Pauroso as Freckles Guy Stevenson as Paramedic Alex Fernie as Bell Ringer #2 Jay Pichardo as Bouncing Fun Land Employee Oliver Lennon as Junior Deputy Joe Warson as Janitor Brad Williams as Keith the Elf Uncredited Niecy Nash as T.T. Kerri Kenney-Silver as Jackie DeMartino