Guest Stars Kevin Daniels as Franklin Darin Toonder as David 'Chip' Merrick McKenzie Chinn as Sheriff Josie Miller Michael Fairman as Merrick Lance Tindall as Triplet Suspect Miles Tindall as Triplet Suspect Jordan Tindall as Triplet Suspect Co Starring Todd Allen Durkin as Captain Dennis Heller Cora Lu Tran as Nico Kurt Yue as Pete Chin Deion Smith as Jeremy Mitchell Beau Hart as Max Ormewood Jophielle Love as Cooper Ormewood Sara Antonio as Gina Ormewood Kendrick Cross as Grady Parnell Amy Parrish as Irene Avery Bigelow as Deputy Riley Michaela Baham as Janie Mike Kaye as Local Man Lindsey Elaine Shope as Nurse Pat Dortch as Otis Ryan King as Young Merrick Avis-Marie Barnes as Theresa Rothwell