Guest Stars Molly Parker as Laura Broder Margo Martindale as Joanna Pierce Tara Nicodemo as Molly Greenfield Shawn Doyle as Eric Broder Marcia Bennett as Judge Moore Kathy Maloney as Broadcast Journalist Billy Parrott as Father Shanda Bezic as Young Woman Arlene Duncan as Meredith Lawson Scott Baker as Police Officer #2 John C. Malcolm as Parent #2 Coko Galore as Bailiff Sean Cage as Mike (TA) Celina Vera as Police Officer #4 Krista Jang as Conspiracist #2 Adrian Rebucas as Parent #1 Ryan Hollyman as Prosecutor Phillip Samuel as Police Officer #1 Catherine McNally as Grief Counselor Billy Turnbull as Conspiracist #1 Liam MacDonald as Jonah Broder Okiki Kendall as Skeptical Mother Ish Morris as Ben Greenfield Samantha Espie as Police Officer #3