Guest Stars Conor Dubin as Danny Robel Evan Arnold as Jeffrey Ambor Troy Evans as Detective Mike Pitts Nancy Lenehan as Patty - Ab's Mom Dom Magwili as Judge P. Teague Keith Sellon-Wright as Psychiatrist Annie Potts as Dr. Marla Dodds Kevin Rahm as Pastor Mark Rayburn Allison Smith as Cindy Delacroix James DuMont as Dave Simon Kari Coleman as Cheryl Swinger John Bishop as Phil Swinger Pete Gardner as Dennis Delacroix Dwayne Adway as Officer Keith Macklin Marie Wong as Medical Examiner Connie Jackson as Detective Walsh Elaine Kao as Newswoman Julie Alexander as Evelyn, The Sister James Ritz as Jury Foreman