Guest Stars Charlie Semine as Nick Valentino K.K. Moggie as Dr. Gillian Jelani Patch Darragh as Tim Flanagan Johnny Hopkins as Bobby Flanagan Victor Williams as Robert Mercer Michael Ian Black as Mark Gunther Marcia DeBonis as Lorraine John Sharian as Al Raymond Amina Robinson as Lena Mercer Co Starring Phil Burke as Reverend Todd Andrew Garman as Dr. Reed Zoe Margaret Colletti as Cydie Marchand Nina Lisandrello as Charmaine Jennifer Restivo as Trisha Saidah Arrika Ekulona as Beverly Mercer Susan-Kate Heaney as Jessica Darlesia Cearcy as Adrienne Mercer Aria Alpert as Melissa Gunther Gavin Lodge as Brendan Krista Hoeppner as Nadia Marchand Kevin Henderson as Mr. Hamel Diana Shneider as Mrs. Hamel