Guest Stars Scott Wolf as Donald 'Donnie' Ryan Brad Rowe as FBI Agent Dalton Laura Slade Wiggins as Patti Wallace Tiffany Boone as Teenage Girl Ray Wise as Martin Sullivan Samuel Hunt as Chad Jim Turner as Dr. Bilson Vanessa Marano as Riley Susan Walters as Anne Wallace Lisa Sheridan as Rebecca Abbott Taylor John Smith as Braden Sullivan Lindsay Bushman as Maddy Damaris Diaz as Zoe Martha Hackett as Leah Sullivan Co Starring David Stifel as Worker Carolyn Ann Clark as Flight Attendant Trevor Doyle Nelson as Shy Guy Velinda Godfrey as Thin Brunette