Guest Stars Robert Pine as Gerry Finnegan Kathleen Rose Perkins as Elise Finnegan David Ramsey as Jim Wheeler Tyler Hoechlin as Dylan Fulton Chet Grissom as Agent Gray Stephanie Faracy as Patty Schultz Co Starring Will Beinbrink as Steven Fletcher Frank Gallegos as Keith Lopez Ilene Graff as Gayle Finnegan Kahlil Joseph as Bank Manager Jennifer Riker as Sue Vaughn