Guest Stars Scott Paulin as Jim Beckett Patrick Fischler as Leo Tony Denison as Michael "Mickey" Dolan Bonita Friedericy as Sister Mary Bart Braverman as Cabbie Jamison Haase as FBI Agent Lucas Jonathan Emerson as Father Joe McMurtry Daniel Steven Gonzalez as Bronx PD Officer Devin McGinn as Colin Clark Bryan Friday as Thug #2 Glenn Herman as Burly Tenant Josh Feinman as Jerry Jenkins