Guest Stars Lurene Tuttle as Mary Emery James MacArthur as Alex Farrelli Marcia Strassman as Kay Penny / Katherine Patrino Henry Jones as Bank Teller William Smith as Wyatt Earp Robert F. Hoy as Slim Dennis Cole as Dr. Lloyd Hopper Edward Andrews as Donny Olan Soulé as Proprietor Christopher Connelly as Bill Cummings Raymond Singer as Larry Dennis Kort as Soda Jerk Hope Olson as Sheba