Guest Stars Heather Grace Hancock as Mallory Kharchenko Talia Toms as Jane Olivia Moss as Mary Vincent Ventresca as Jimmy Lovett Kascee Murdock as Freddie Beaumontaine Lola Wayne Villa as Tiffany Beaumontaine Tanner Stine as Mitch Mary Stein as Librarian Keith Sellon-Wright as Ted Kale Clauson as Spicoli