Guest Stars Michael Stahl-David as Will Ingram April L. Hernandez as Andrea Gutierrez Vito D'Ambrosio as Dominic Galuska Curtiss Cook as Terrence Hill Alex Cranmer as Chris Scollard Tuck Kinsey as Paul Kinsey Co Starring Tuck Milligan as Finch’s Father Eric Ruffin as Jacob King Brian O'Neill as Judge Peterson Starla Benford as Gloria Copeland Barbara Pitts as Melissa Kinsey Jesse J. Perez as Dishwasher James Lloyd Reynolds as Slick Attorney