Guest Stars Molly Hagan as Daisy May Eloy Casados as Yavapai Elder Matt Roth as Philip Dagmar Dale Midkiff as Sheriff Conklin Keith Szarabajka as James Grady Tyler Hilton as Tobias Matt Burns as James 'Ollie' Oliver Tim De Zarn as Bartender Hector Hugo as Dr. Neville Co Starring Sarah Butler as Whitney Williams Kim Johnston Ulrich as Lenanne Dagmar Angela Relucio as Paramedic David Atkinson as U.S. Marshal Yolanda Snowball as Rebecca Doolin Mike Agresta as Dealer Uncredited Sarah Bailey as New Horizon Staff Alicia Fusting as Barmaid Anika C. McFall as Ella Edward Caldwell as Cowboy Michael Joseph as John Duda Marty Kimble as Deputy Sheriff Jasper Salon as ER Nurse