Guest Stars Maria Thayer as Annie Co Starring Hannah Duncan as Waitress Alanna Masterson as Mopey Hipster Girl Ozioma Akagha as Party Girl Gary Kraus as Officer David Douglas as Tripping Guy Allan McLeod as Partygoer Michelle Pascarella as Young Girl Leena Huff as Neal's Girl Tyler Peck as Party Guy Syd Wilder as Kardashian Girl