Guest Stars Gina Gallego as Mrs. Hernandez Rene Gube as Father Joseph / "Father Brah" Olivia Edward as Madison Whitefeather Stephnie Weir as Karen Ava Acres as Young Rebecca Allison Dunbar as Stacy Whitefeather Co Starring Michael McMillian as Tim Burl Moseley as Jim Kittsworth Molly Pan as Bartender Vance Valencia as Judge Eileen Galindo as Joyce the Homeless Woman Paul Mabon as Sound Guy Denise Dorado as Woman at Home Base Uncredited Tovah Feldshuh voices Naomi Bunch